Some SEO consultants have stated that Google is now issuing more manual actions than usual in the past few months. Google itself has not confirmed this. According to Barry Schwartz of Search Engine Roundtable, who posted the claims on October 8th, 2026, the news was drawn from discussions among experienced consultants and a scan of Google’s help forums.
The information is anecdotal in nature, and it should be treated as such. However, the pattern of manual actions reported do point to a certain trend. Here’s what the SEO consultants are claiming, what a manual action actually is, and what site owners can do in response.
What Seos Are Reporting
Schwartz noted that Google could be issuing more manual actions over the past few weeks than it saw in the weeks preceding. The increase appears to have begun several weeks ago, he noted, and seems to have accelerated in recent times, according to some SEOs.
He added a bit of history: Manual action complaints were rampant about a decade or more ago, he said. They receded as Google algorithms were seen to do most of the hard work. Now complaints are creeping back. They are not back to old levels, but they are higher than a few months ago.
From Almost None To Several A Week
Marie Haynes was the first to talk about this trend on X. She has been doing manual action consulting for the last 20 years or so. She said that she has recently witnessed a significant increase in inquiries about manual actions.
She told Schwartz that her requests for help used to be “essentially zero” and now number several per week. She said she stopped advertising or talking about manual action consulting, which makes the increase even more surprising. She also said the volume was nowhere close to the days of Google’s Penguin algorithm update.
The manual actions she sees usually relate to thin content, spam, or scaled content. She said that most of the sites impacted are legitimate, established companies. This observation is important because it suggests that these are not mere throwaway spam sites.
A Consultant’s Warning About Shortcuts
Another SEO, Daniel Foley Carter, has also commented on the situation. In his X post, he mentioned that he sees an influx of manual actions and believes that they are coming from all over, and some of them seem to be growing more and more over the last few months.
He blames ‘shortcuts’ in the industry and said that a part of the SEO sector had resorted to using scaled content abuse for a short-term win. He said some companies had reduced their SEO budgets because they thought the artificial intelligence could do their job, and those lower-level SEOs resorted to AI to scale their content. This is what people like him are now cleaning up.
Besides, he gave a warning about manual actions. He explained that the impact of manual actions could be devastating, with a traffic loss of over 90 percent for some websites. However, this is not necessarily Google’s data, but it represents extreme cases.
What The Forums Show
Schwartz also went through the Google Webmaster Help Forums and picked out recent threads. Their titles show the pattern. Several mention “major spam problems” affecting a /blog/ section. Others cover thin content actions, scaled content abuse, and pure spam. One thread describes a thin content action despite removing 4,000 URLs. Another describes three rejected reconsideration requests despite a cleanup of more than 6,000 URLs.
He then asked ChatGPT and Gemini to review the forums and say whether complaints had spiked. Both said there were more complaints, but not a very large spike. When he asked each to draw a chart, the data differed between them. Schwartz joked about that himself. It is a loose check, not a measurement.
What A Manual Action Is
Google’s spam policies page describes possible violations of their policies. According to Google, they identify infringements of their rules through automated processes and, if necessary, manually. If a website violates Google’s usage rules, the company has the right to reduce its rating in search results or remove it from the search engine.
Google’s manual actions help page indicates that the most common type of manual action is used to combat attempts to manipulate the search index. In addition, the report on manual actions in the Search Console contains a summary of all manual actions applied to the website. In cases when a site is penalized globally, all links on the pages controlled by the site are affected. Global actions are much more severe than local algorithmic adjustments, and thus have a more significant impact on the ranking of sites.
Finally, while algorithmic adjustments, such as the September 2026 update, are implemented automatically, manual actions require a detailed analysis of the site’s content and quality by Google moderators. After identifying violations of Google’s guidelines, the company notifies the website owner directly through the Search Console.
Common Types In The Conversation
Carter gave a list of manual actions that website owners could be subjected to. These issues were grouped according to categories in Google’s spam policies. Some of these are back button hijacking, user generated spam, unnatural links to and from a site, thin content with little or no added value, cloaking and sneaky redirects, major spam issues, hidden text and keyword stuffing, and violations of site reputation policy. In addition, Carter’s list also included structured data issues, spammy free hosts, cloaked images, AMP content mismatch, and sneaky mobile redirects.
According to Carter, this list only covers some of the issues that are reported in Search Console. He stated that the flags are generated by automated spam systems, user spam reports, or regular quality sweeps before a reviewer decides.
How Recovery Works
Google’s help page describes the approach. If there are multiple manual actions, it is necessary to study and eliminate all of them. When the problem is solved, and there are no violations of the spam policy, you need to click on the Request review button in the Manual actions report.
Google notes that a proper resubmission describes the changes made. After resubmission, you will receive a confirmation that the review has started. According to Google, it is necessary not to resubmit until a response comes in with a final conclusion.
Review of the submission may take some time. Google notes that the duration varies from several days to several weeks, and requests related to links usually take longer. Threads on the forum concerning repeated rejections indicate that one cleanup may not be enough.
Does This Connect To The Spam Update?
The timing overlaps. Google finished rolling out its September 2026 spam update on October 8. But none of the sources link the update to the manual action reports. Schwartz did not claim a connection, and Google has not commented. Treat them as separate until evidence says otherwise.
What Site Owners Should Do
The sources don’t give a checklist, so these are just suggestions in line with what Google’s pages say. Go to manual actions report in search console and check the count, then compare against spam policies, particularly scaled content abuse, thin, and third party content. Check for hacked or injected pages.
If you have an action, fix every cause before requesting a review and keep track of what you changed. Quick, superficial cleanups seem to just fail according to the forum threads.
Frequently asked questions
Q 1: Is Google issuing more manual actions?
Some SEOs claim that Google is doing so. Google has not officially commented on these reports. The only evidence we have so far comes from consultants and forum posts.
Q 2: Who first reported the trend?
Marie Haynes announced it on Twitter/X. Daniel Foley Carter also reported that he is seeing an increase. Barry Schwartz of Search Engine Roundtable published an article about it on October 8th, 2026.
Q 3: What kinds of manual actions are being reported?
Haynes listed thin content, spam, and scaled content as possible issues. The forum posts also mention a big problem with spammy blogs sections.
Q 4: Are only spammy sites affected?
Most of the sites Ms. Haynes mentioned are reputable organizations that have been around for a while — that’s her opinion, based on her observations as a consultant.
Q 5: How is a manual action different from an algorithm update?
A manual action is taken by a person, not a computer. Google states that “violations of Google’s policies are identified by automated processes or, in certain cases, manually by Google employees”. The website owner sees a notification about a manual action in Search Console.
Q 6: How long does a reconsideration review take?
Google says most take several days or weeks. Link-related requests may take longer.
Q 7: Can I resubmit if I am waiting?
Google says not to resubmit before you get a final decision on your open request.
Q 8: What if I have more than one manual action?
Google says to read about and fix all of them before asking for review.
Q 9: Is this tied to the September 2026 spam update?
No one is certain what caused the wave of manual actions. The timing coincides with the recent spam update, but no one has proven a direct connection.




